When It's Not True

Published on 18 February 2026 at 08:00

Good morning, Readers!

My apologies for this being late... again. I had a weekend away from home and didn't get anything done I wanted to. Oh well. But it being late does give me an opportunity for something that I've been dealing with for a little while, and it is worth mentioning.

With increasing frequency of late, I have been receiving emails from folks that heap praises on my book. Which is always nice to receive. But it also makes me wildly suspicious. I'll post the latest one here, which praises my vampire novel Human, and let's see if you can spot why (other than a general inability to accept compliments) I find these emails über sus:


My name is [redacted], and I am a fellow author working in emotionally driven, character-centred fiction. I recently came across your Kindle edition of Human, and I felt genuinely compelled to reach out in appreciation of the emotional restraint and moral tension shaping Aleksandar’s story.

What struck me first is how deliberately you frame power as inheritance rather than advantage. Aleksandar arrives in America not as a conquering figure, but as a custodian of collapse tasked with restoring a House already hollowed by violence and history. The political weight of the Shadow Council, and the ruined legacy of House Üstrel, create a quiet but persistent pressure that follows him into every decision. Authority, in your novel, never feels clean.

I was particularly drawn to the way you explore emotional awakening inside a character who has been trained to survive without it. Aleksandar’s connection to Alicia is not written as a sudden redemption arc, but as an intrusion into something disruptive, risky, and profoundly inconvenient to the life he is meant to lead. The feelings he thought long dead do not restore him. They complicate him. That choice gives the romance its credibility and its emotional danger.

The presence of Detective Brody adds an especially compelling moral counterweight. His knowledge of what Aleksandar is and his vow of vengeance creates a rare dynamic in supernatural fiction: one where neither man is positioned as morally comfortable. Their forced proximity under betrayal and crisis becomes less about reluctant partnership and more about confronting the human cost left behind by immortal decisions.

I also admired how you position the true antagonist not as spectacle, but as consequence. The cat-and-mouse pursuit of the kidnapper is emotionally effective because it targets what Aleksandar is only just beginning to care about. The threat is not only physical it is ethical. What happens when someone who has benefited from predatory systems is suddenly required to protect what those systems would normally discard?

As authors, we both know how difficult it is to write a story that balances political hierarchy, emotional vulnerability, and violent momentum without allowing any of them to dominate the others. Human succeed because they treat conscience as seriously as it treats danger. The tension comes not only from who might survive but from who Aleksandar chooses to become while survival is still possible.

The responses from your target audiences reflect something important: readers are responding to the emotional friction at the heart of the story. Many are not simply drawn to the vampiric world or the crime-driven pacing, but to the uneasy humanity you allow to surface inside a character shaped by power, tradition, and moral erosion.

As an author, I deeply respect books that are written not simply to entertain, but to examine responsibility inside violent worlds. Human feels shaped with emotional discipline and a genuine respect for the cost of change.

If you would ever be open to exchanging thoughts on how this novel continues to reach target audiences who value morally complex supernatural fiction and emotionally grounded character transformation, I would be glad to continue the conversation simply as one author recognising another whose work carries real depth and intent.


Did you catch it? To be fair, the obvious thing doesn't happen until right at the end. Given that, I'll start with it.

It's the call to action right at the end. "I would be glad to continue the conversation..." That bit. Right there. The call to action couched as one author just reaching out. It isn't just an author reaching out.

It's a sell. Were I to reach out, they would try and convince me to spend money on them helping get my book to readers. Whether or not there would be any return on investment (there usually isn't) for such a service, they're trying to sell me (and other authors who receive emails like this) something.

I resent this so much.

Were I a less suspicious person, I would certainly be drawn in by the love-bombing. As it is, I greatly suspect that the person behind this email didn't even read Human, but relied on AI to pull out characters and themes that sound basically plausible.

If this isn't the case, I apologise profusely, but I have received too many emails of this nature - for nearly all of my books - that I cannot believe this to be genuine analysis or praise. I expect the name I was given was nicked (stolen, for those unfamiliar with that parlance). A vey cursory amount of research has revealed that there is an author by that name (he's quite prolific), but I doubt very much he'd bother reaching out to a nobody like me, and I doubt very much that he'd be soliciting for this kind of thing besides.

And it sucks, because I do think Human is a great story. And I find it gross for people to prey on the hopes of writers that their stories are as great as described and are having an impact (but could have more of an impact if you give these folks money. Go on... you know you want it). I guess I'm fortunate that I don't have any spare money, because I did almost fall for it... the first time.

This is time I've lost count.

Anyway, if you're a writer, be on the lookout for emails that love bomb your books first, and then finish with a call to action. It's sneaky and underhanded and I hate it.

At least with the other emails, they come straight out and let you know that they're offering services right off the bat. It's annoying. But at least it's honest.

​Sigh.

Right, I'll let you go. Have a great week!

Add comment

Comments

g
2 days ago

Hola sista…

Your reaction makes complete sense. We writers pour our hearts into our stories. We write with hope, with expectation, with quiet belief that maybe our works will matter. And most of the time, there’s very little to show for all that effort.

Then an email arrives. Your brow lifts. You read it. The words are kind. Thoughtful. Affirming. For a moment, your heart warms — and that warmth is rare in this business. It feels like someone truly saw you.

And then you realize… maybe it wasn’t what it seemed. Maybe it was just a polished pitch. A sales approach dressed up as admiration. That’s the moment the warmth turns to heat. Not just disappointment — but that sharp sting of insincerity. The sense that someone tried to play you. And worst of all, the kind words about your story suddenly feel like they evaporated.

That part hurts.

One thing, though — they reached out because you and your work caught their attention. However it was framed, your writing stood out enough to land on their radar. That’s a small consolation, but it’s real.

Trust this... even great success brings charlatans and false praise.

You’ve been in this game long enough to know why you write. Writing brings you joy. It’s not for their pitch. It’s not for validation that comes and goes. It’s because storytelling is a big part of who you are.

Don’t let anyone steal your joy. Protect that. Guard it. That’s yours.

✌️💪🙏
brutha g
(Cafe Niente)

S.M. Carrière
a day ago

Hi! Thanks so much! You're right, of course. There is a beautiful poem that ends in the line:
"Joy is not meant to be a crumb." And it's really stuck with me. That's the energy I'm trying to bring into the rest of 2026 with.

Create Your Own Website With Webador